Great post, David. Such a rich history in your 4 names! I echo your point that our names tell a story and want to add a bit more. Our names are part of our identity, thus when someone opts not to take the effort you describe to know the names of those who you work with or (hopefully not) makes fun of someone's name through mispronunciation or otherwise it can have a deep, undermining impact on that person, their pursuits, and how others see and treat them. I continually have this concern in teaching law because much of traditional legal education is been framed around stripping away what a student knows and replacing it with "thinking like a lawyer". What does that say about how one's story and identity fit into the law? What does that mean for whether and how the law can change and grow?
If learning the law is new to non-traditional and first gen students, then all they have is their story and identity to build on - and we need to reinforce that foundation. The consequences if we do not can be dire.
You are imploring educators on all levels to embrace the story and identity of each and every one of their students. I can think of no better message to start the school year. Thank you.
Cliff, what a thoughtful addition! Indeed, names do connect very deeply with identity. I grew up on the stories about my grandparents (who died when I was 4), the small town they dedicated their lives to, and about my Uncle David. They are deeply imprinted on me in ways too numerous and interwoven to fully tease apart and describe.
You are right, of course, that the current system of legal education does tend to strip out the identity of the individual, and mis-handling of student names can be a part of that. I think there is more to say and explore there. I appreciate your highlighting the importance of embracing each student's story. Thank you!
First, thank you for the shout-out, it's always appreciated and I'm always happy to see a new post by you in my inbox.
Second, and much more importantly, the letter from your grandfather to the town is beautiful. To be remembered so fondly is evidence of a life well-lived.
So, on to names - I'm fascinated by the use of Irish as a name is new to me. Is or was that a common name? Does it come from the country of Ireland or is it a coincidence? I guess it sticks out to me because it's an adjective rather than a noun - using a place name as a person't name isn't all that uncommon, but I'm hard pressed to think of adjective...
As for my own name, Mom had actually planned to name me David! But she worked as an elementary school teacher and had three different Davids in her class while she was pregnant. So she opted for her second favorite biblical name, Joel. She has told me since that if she had re-read the book of Joel while pregnant, I would have been Josh or possibly even Jonah. As it stands, Joel became my first name and David became my middle name.
And it causes no end of problems. Japan doesn't have middle names and so the forms and online fields that you mentioned often are not provided for middle names. And yet it's in my passport so it must be included...it leads to all kinds of confusion, but such is life.
Hi Joel, thank you for once again a close read of my post and a thoughtful response. That letter my grandfather wrote always seems to me more poetry than letter. I did not know him as a poet, but having been to that small town at that time of year several times, it does capture the beauty of the place by the river in the fall.
I always wondered about Irish as a surname too, it being a part of my full name. Yes, Irish people did settle in large numbers in Newfoundland in the 18th Century. But the name... I can tell you (from a family tree sent to me by my Uncle Dick, who visited there in 1981, and compiled it) that Robert Irish lived in Battle Harbour, Labrador in 1795, and there was a John Irish in Fogo in 1803. He got that information from an interesting book: Family Names of the Island of Newfoundland, originally published in 1977. In the extensive introduction the author, E. R. Seary, discusses the historic and linguistic origins of Newfoundland surnames and their cultural sources – notably English, Welsh, Irish, Scottish, French, Syrian, Lebanese and Micmac. But it only lists a few people with the surname Irish, and does not explain its origins. It seems likely though that they were subsistence fishermen and farmers who came to Newfoundland without surnames, and were just called Irish (because they were) and it stuck.
There were four (!) Davids in my second grade class, and so my second grade teacher - Mrs. Bovers - had to come up with different versions to keep us straight. A David and a Dave perhaps (I forget exactly), but she decided to call me "I.C." When I would see her years later in the neighborhood, she still called me that. Only person who ever has.
Great post, David. Such a rich history in your 4 names! I echo your point that our names tell a story and want to add a bit more. Our names are part of our identity, thus when someone opts not to take the effort you describe to know the names of those who you work with or (hopefully not) makes fun of someone's name through mispronunciation or otherwise it can have a deep, undermining impact on that person, their pursuits, and how others see and treat them. I continually have this concern in teaching law because much of traditional legal education is been framed around stripping away what a student knows and replacing it with "thinking like a lawyer". What does that say about how one's story and identity fit into the law? What does that mean for whether and how the law can change and grow?
If learning the law is new to non-traditional and first gen students, then all they have is their story and identity to build on - and we need to reinforce that foundation. The consequences if we do not can be dire.
You are imploring educators on all levels to embrace the story and identity of each and every one of their students. I can think of no better message to start the school year. Thank you.
Cliff.
Cliff, what a thoughtful addition! Indeed, names do connect very deeply with identity. I grew up on the stories about my grandparents (who died when I was 4), the small town they dedicated their lives to, and about my Uncle David. They are deeply imprinted on me in ways too numerous and interwoven to fully tease apart and describe.
You are right, of course, that the current system of legal education does tend to strip out the identity of the individual, and mis-handling of student names can be a part of that. I think there is more to say and explore there. I appreciate your highlighting the importance of embracing each student's story. Thank you!
Hi David,
I've got a few thoughts:
First, thank you for the shout-out, it's always appreciated and I'm always happy to see a new post by you in my inbox.
Second, and much more importantly, the letter from your grandfather to the town is beautiful. To be remembered so fondly is evidence of a life well-lived.
So, on to names - I'm fascinated by the use of Irish as a name is new to me. Is or was that a common name? Does it come from the country of Ireland or is it a coincidence? I guess it sticks out to me because it's an adjective rather than a noun - using a place name as a person't name isn't all that uncommon, but I'm hard pressed to think of adjective...
As for my own name, Mom had actually planned to name me David! But she worked as an elementary school teacher and had three different Davids in her class while she was pregnant. So she opted for her second favorite biblical name, Joel. She has told me since that if she had re-read the book of Joel while pregnant, I would have been Josh or possibly even Jonah. As it stands, Joel became my first name and David became my middle name.
And it causes no end of problems. Japan doesn't have middle names and so the forms and online fields that you mentioned often are not provided for middle names. And yet it's in my passport so it must be included...it leads to all kinds of confusion, but such is life.
Great post!
Hi Joel, thank you for once again a close read of my post and a thoughtful response. That letter my grandfather wrote always seems to me more poetry than letter. I did not know him as a poet, but having been to that small town at that time of year several times, it does capture the beauty of the place by the river in the fall.
I always wondered about Irish as a surname too, it being a part of my full name. Yes, Irish people did settle in large numbers in Newfoundland in the 18th Century. But the name... I can tell you (from a family tree sent to me by my Uncle Dick, who visited there in 1981, and compiled it) that Robert Irish lived in Battle Harbour, Labrador in 1795, and there was a John Irish in Fogo in 1803. He got that information from an interesting book: Family Names of the Island of Newfoundland, originally published in 1977. In the extensive introduction the author, E. R. Seary, discusses the historic and linguistic origins of Newfoundland surnames and their cultural sources – notably English, Welsh, Irish, Scottish, French, Syrian, Lebanese and Micmac. But it only lists a few people with the surname Irish, and does not explain its origins. It seems likely though that they were subsistence fishermen and farmers who came to Newfoundland without surnames, and were just called Irish (because they were) and it stuck.
There were four (!) Davids in my second grade class, and so my second grade teacher - Mrs. Bovers - had to come up with different versions to keep us straight. A David and a Dave perhaps (I forget exactly), but she decided to call me "I.C." When I would see her years later in the neighborhood, she still called me that. Only person who ever has.